With the songs written, Joel tapped Max Hart (War on Drugs, Tegan & Sara, Melissa Etheridge, We are Scientists) to produce the record. Together, they whittled down collection of the 70+ songs Daniel had written to a more manageable number.
Hart enlisted some stellar musicians to play on the project including Jon Natchez (War on Drugs, Beirut), Luke Reynolds (Guster, Neko Case, Phosphorescent, Sharon Van Etten), and Eric Gardener (Tom Morello, Melissa Etheridge). A substantial amount being recorded in Austin with Britton Beisenherz (Clap Your Hands Say Yeah, Marie/Lepanto, Will Johnson, Little Mazarn) of Ramble Creek Studio.